How to Cook a Steak Indoors to Perfection: A Step-by-Step Guide
Key Takeaways: What Makes Authentic Argentine Empanada Dough Different?
If there’s one thing I’ve learned after living in Argentina for more than twenty-three years, it’s that Argentines judge an empanada long before they taste the filling.
They look at the repulgue first. Then they feel the dough. If it’s too thick, too pale, too flaky, too humid, or too dry, they’ve already made up their mind.
Most recipes online treat empanada dough as an afterthought. They’ll spend pages discussing the filling, then tell you to mix flour and butter together and hope for the best. That’s not how it’s done here.
Every Sunday, my suegra (mom-in-law) makes empanadas from scratch. It’s a ritual I’ve watched countless times. The filling changes depending on the season (or if we are using leftovers from the asado the night before), but the dough follows the same principles every time. It has to be soft enough to fold without cracking, strong enough to hold a juicy filling, and tender enough to bite through cleanly after baking or frying.
That’s what this recipe will explain.
You’ll also notice one ingredient that surprises many people outside Argentina.
Traditional empanada dough is often made with grasa vacuna (rendered beef fat) rather than butter. That single ingredient gives Argentine empanadas their distinctive texture and flavor. If you’ve eaten empanadas in Salta, Mendoza, Tucumán, or Buenos Aires and wondered why they tasted different from homemade recipes elsewhere, this is usually the reason.
In this guide I’ll show you exactly how we make masa para empanadas at home, when to use beef fat, lard, or butter, how thick to roll the dough, and why resting it is every bit as important as kneading it.
One of the biggest misconceptions is that all empanada dough is basically the same.
It isn’t.
The dough used throughout Argentina has evolved specifically to hold juicy fillings containing onions, beef, chicken, olives, boiled eggs, or melted cheese without falling apart.
Unlike puff pastry (or a cornish pasty for example), it shouldn’t separate into dozens of flaky layers.
Unlike pie crust, it shouldn’t crumble.
Unlike pizza dough, it shouldn’t become chewy.
Instead, Argentine empanada dough sits somewhere in the middle.
It has just enough elasticity to stretch around the filling while remaining tender after cooking.
| Style | Texture | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Argentine dough | Soft, tender, sturdy | Juicy meat fillings |
| Mexican empanada dough | Sweeter, often thicker | Dessert or sweet fillings |
| Spanish empanada dough | Bread-like | Large family pies (Empanada Gallega) |
| Puff pastry | Very flaky | Pastries, not traditional Argentine empanadas |
This is why you’ll rarely find puff pastry used in traditional Argentine homes for empanada casings. It simply can’t contain the juices properly.
Like most Argentine cooking, the ingredient list is surprisingly short. What matters is choosing the right fat and respecting the ratios.
For approximately 18–20 medium empanadas, you’ll need:
You’ll notice there’s no baking powder.
Traditional Argentine empanada dough isn’t designed to rise. The dough stays relatively flat while becoming beautifully tender after cooking.
If you ask a butcher in Argentina what makes authentic empanadas, chances are they’ll answer before you’ve finished the question.
Grasa.
Rendered beef fat has been used for generations because Argentina has been a cattle-producing country since pretty much day one.
It creates a dough that stays crisp without becoming brittle. It also adds a subtle savory flavor that butter simply can’t match.
This is especially common in northern provinces like Salta and Tucumán, where beef fat remains the standard for traditional empanadas.
If you can’t find beef fat, lard is the next closest option. Butter works perfectly well, but expect a softer dough with a richer dairy flavor rather than the characteristic texture found throughout Argentina.
| Fat | Authenticity | Texture | Recommended |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beef fat (grasa vacuna) | ★★★★★ | Crisp, sturdy | Best overall |
| Lard | ★★★★☆ | Tender and flaky | Excellent substitute |
| Butter | ★★★☆☆ | Softer | Good if beef fat isn’t available |
| Vegetable oil | ★☆☆☆☆ | Less structured | Only if necessary |
If you’ve ever wondered why empanadas in Argentina taste different from recipes you’ve tried elsewhere, this is usually the answer.
This is the stage many recipes skip.
It’s also one of the biggest reasons homemade empanadas crack while folding.
Wrap the dough tightly or cover it with a damp cloth.
Allow it to rest for 30–60 minutes at room temperature.
During this time the gluten relaxes, making the dough significantly easier to roll and preventing it from shrinking back every time you use the rolling pin.
Professional empanada makers never skip this step. Neither should you.
Argentine empanada dough is thinner than many people expect.
Aim for approximately 2–3 mm, or about the thickness of two stacked coins. Anything thinner risks tearing when you add juicy fillings, and anything thicker creates doughy edges that overpower the filling.
Use a round cutter between 12–14 cm (4¾–5½ inches) depending on the size of empanadas you prefer.
If you’re making the classic beef filling, this size provides the perfect balance between dough and filling.
The next step is filling, sealing, and mastering the repulgue, the signature fold that immediately tells an Argentine whether an empanada has been made properly.
One question I hear regularly is whether you need two completely different dough recipes for baked and fried empanadas.
The answer is no.
The base dough is almost identical, but there are a couple of small adjustments that make a noticeable difference.
If you’re baking your empanadas, the dough can be rolled slightly thinner because it isn’t exposed to the shock of hot oil. Baking also dries the surface slightly, producing the golden shell most Argentines expect.
For fried empanadas, particularly the style you’ll find in Salta, the dough benefits from being just a fraction thicker. An extra half millimeter helps it withstand the pressure of bubbling oil while still staying tender inside.
The fat also matters.
Traditional fried empanadas are often made with grasa vacuna because the dough crisps beautifully without becoming greasy. Butter-based dough tends to brown faster and can become softer after frying.
For baking, brush each empanada with beaten egg before placing them into a preheated oven at 200°C / 400°F for around 18–22 minutes, depending on their size.
For frying, heat oil to 175°C / 350°F and cook for approximately 3–4 minutes, turning once until evenly golden.
The dough should be lightly crisp on the outside while remaining soft enough to bite through without shattering.
Ask any Argentine what makes a beautiful empanada and many won’t mention the filling first.
They’ll mention the repulgue. A good repulgue in Argentina is often referred too as: “Una obra de arte!” (A work of art!)
The repulgue is the decorative folded edge that seals the empanada. Beyond looking attractive, it performs an important job: keeping every drop of juice inside during cooking.
If you’ve spent time in Argentina, you’ll notice many families even use different repulgues to identify different fillings. Beef might have one pattern, chicken another, ham and cheese another. Others put “labels” or signs on the dough using a fork to prick the casing, with different amounts of holes labeling the filling.
My suegra never needs labels. She knows what’s inside every empanada simply by looking at the fold.
The biggest mistake beginners make isn’t the dough. It’s trying to fit too much filling inside.
A medium-sized empanada only needs around 2 tablespoons of filling.
That might not sound like much, but remember the filling expands as it cooks.
Too much filling stretches the dough, weakens the seal, and almost always leads to leaks.
When meat juices escape onto the baking tray or into the frying oil, they create steam that softens the dough instead of allowing it to crisp properly.
Less filling usually produces a better empanada.
Before folding, leave approximately 1 cm (½ inch) of clean dough around the edge.
Any grease, onion, or meat touching the edge prevents the dough from sealing properly.
If necessary, lightly moisten the border with water before folding the dough over. This will help your repulgue and also help the dough to unify.
Press firmly with your fingertips before beginning the repulgue. The fold should reinforce the seal, not create it.
Like learning to light a fire or cook over a Argentine parrilla, the repulgue becomes muscle memory.
Your first few may look uneven. That’s completely normal.
By the tenth batch you’ll barely need to think about it.
One of the things I love about making empanadas is that every family has their own style. Some folds are large and dramatic. Others are small and incredibly neat. None are wrong.
The important thing is that the seal holds.
Making good dough isn’t difficult.
Avoiding these mistakes is what separates average empanadas from great ones.
Cold fat doesn’t distribute evenly through the flour.
Always melt beef fat or lard gently before mixing.
It should be warm, never hot.
Many people continue adding flour while kneading because the dough feels sticky.
Give it another minute first.
As gluten develops, the dough naturally becomes smoother.
Adding too much flour produces dry, heavy empanadas.
If the dough keeps shrinking every time you roll it, the gluten hasn’t relaxed.
Resting isn’t optional.
Thirty minutes makes an enormous difference.
Thin dough may look elegant on the bench.
It usually tears once the filling heats up.
Aim for around 2–3 mm consistently across the entire disc.
This surprises many people.
A juicy filling actually protects the dough.
Traditional Argentine beef fillings contain onions, rendered fat, and natural cooking juices.
Dry meat creates dry empanadas regardless of how well the dough is made.
If you’re looking for the filling I use most often, you’ll find the full recipe in my guide to Argentine beef empanadas, where I cover everything from the traditional recado to folding techniques and cooking methods.
Absolutely. In fact, many Argentine families prepare several batches at once.
Wrap the dough tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate for up to 48 hours before using.
For longer storage, freeze the dough for up to three months. When you’re ready to use it, transfer it to the refrigerator the night before.
Avoid thawing at room temperature. Slow thawing helps preserve the dough’s texture and makes it much easier to roll.
You can also freeze assembled, uncooked empanadas. Arrange them on a tray until frozen solid before transferring them to freezer bags. (top tip = use a dedicated freezer paper between the tray and the empanada)
This prevents them from sticking together. Cook directly from frozen.
Simply add 3–5 extra minutes to the baking time.
After watching my suegra make empanadas for more than 6 years, I’ve learned that great empanadas don’t begin with the filling.
They begin with the dough. When the dough is soft enough to fold, strong enough to hold the juices, and tender enough to bite through cleanly, almost any traditional filling will shine.
Don’t worry if your first repulgues aren’t perfect. Every Argentine family has their own style, and that’s part of what makes empanadas so special. The more often you make them, the more natural the process becomes.
Once you’ve mastered this dough, you’re ready for the fun part: choosing your filling.
I recommend starting with my authentic Argentine Beef Empanada Recipe, where you’ll learn how to prepare the classic beef filling, season it properly, and assemble the empanadas from start to finish.
No. Puff pastry is far flakier and doesn’t support juicy fillings the way traditional Argentine empanada dough does.
Rendered beef fat (grasa vacuna) produces the most authentic flavor and texture. Lard is an excellent substitute, while butter creates a softer dough.
Roll the dough to approximately 2–3 mm, about the thickness of two stacked coins.
Yes. Wrap it tightly and freeze for up to three months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before rolling.
The dough usually hasn’t rested long enough or is too dry. Rest it for at least 30 minutes and avoid adding excess flour during kneading.
Discover the first-ever English-speaking Argentine Asado DIY Building Guide, a digital experience designed to help you build your own authentic Asado grill, master the craft of Argentine grilling, and join our community that lives and breathes fire, food, and tradition.
Key Takeaways There is a particular kind of guilt among people who love Argentine food and live in a flat. No patio, no parrilla, no legal way to burn wood four floors up, and a craving for vacío on a Sunday. The usual advice is to buy a grill pan and make peace with it. […]
KEY TAKEAWAYS For years I treated a frozen steak as a mistake to be corrected. You forgot to plan, so now you stand at the sink running water over a vacuum-sealed brick and hoping for the best. Then I started testing it properly, and the conclusion was uncomfortable: a steak cooked straight from frozen, done […]
KEY TAKEAWAYS Argentinian Chimichurri Sauce: The Authentic Recipe and How to Use It Every asado in Argentina has a jar of chimichurri on the table, and almost none of them came out of a blender. That is the first thing to understand about authentic argentinian chimichurri sauce, and it is the thing most recipes outside […]
