How to Spice Chicken for Grilling: Essential Herbs and Spices
Most pan-seared ribeye recipes do the same thing: salt, pepper, hot pan, butter, thyme, done. That works. But it is not what I use. After 23 years of cooking steak in Argentina, the seasoning I reach for is mustard seeds, dried chimichurri, and marine salt — a combination that builds a crust with a depth and texture that coarse pepper cannot match.
The technique matters as much as the seasoning. Room temperature for a full hour before the pan, not 20 minutes. Sear both sides first before any butter or aromatics go in, because butter burns at searing temperature and you need that heat for a proper crust. Render the fat cap vertically for three minutes, standing on its edge, before the second side goes down. Most recipes skip this entirely. It is where a significant portion of the flavour lives.
This is a pan-seared ribeye steak recipe using the method I developed cooking in a Buenos Aires kitchen when the parrilla is not an option. It takes about 12 minutes of active cooking and produces a steak with a proper Argentine character: a dark, spiced crust, a medium-rare centre at 130°F / 54°C, and the pan butter poured over the top when it goes to the board.
Key takeaways
Ribeye steak takes 3 to 4 minutes per side in a very hot cast iron pan, plus 1 to 1.5 minutes on the fat cap, for medium-rare at 130°F / 54°C. The steak must be at room temperature for at least 1 hour before cooking. Add butter and aromatics only after the initial sear. Add them before and the butter burns before the crust forms. Rest for 2 to 3 minutes before slicing. Always slice against the grain.
In Argentina, ribeye is called ojo de bife — eye of beef. It is the boneless center cut from the rib primal, without the ribeye cap. What Americans call the New York strip is bife de chorizo in Argentina — confusingly named, nothing to do with sausage. Understanding these names matters when you are buying from an Argentine butcher, ordering in Buenos Aires, or following recipes written in Spanish.
Argentine ribeye is almost exclusively grass-fed. The texture is leaner than American grain-fed beef, the marbling is lighter, and the flavour has a more mineral, earthy character. It is not inferior — it is different. Grass-fed ribeye also cooks roughly 30% faster than grain-fed at the same thickness. If you are working with Argentine or other grass-fed beef, reduce each sear by about 30 to 45 seconds and check the internal temperature earlier than the timings below suggest.
The Argentine beef cut guide goes deeper on the full range of cuts: vacío, matambre, tira de asado, and explains how Argentine butchery differs from American and European systems. Worth reading if you plan to cook beyond the ribeye.
Thickness is the most important variable for a pan-seared ribeye. Under 1 inch and the steak overcooks before the crust develops. Over 2 inches and the inside stays cold while the outside chars. The target is 1 to 1.5 inches — thick enough for a proper crust-to-interior ratio, thin enough to cook through without needing an oven finish.
Marbling is the second factor. Look for white fat running through the muscle, not just a fat cap on the edge. That intramuscular fat melts during cooking and bastes the meat from the inside. A lean ribeye with no marbling is closer to a sirloin in the pan — it will be dry. For grass-fed beef, accept lighter marbling, because the flavour compensates. For why Argentine grass-fed beef carries less marbling but more depth, that article explains the pasture and breed factors.
Freshness: bright red and firm to the touch. Avoid anything grey at the edges or tacky on the surface. If buying packaged, smell it when you open it — a faint iron smell is fine, anything sulphurous is not.
The bone does not conduct heat into the muscle. This is a persistent myth. What it does do is add weight, making the steak harder to hold flat against the pan. A bone-in ribeye requires more attention to keep even contact across the surface. The tomahawk is a bone-in ribeye with the full rib bone attached and needs a different approach entirely. The tomahawk steak guide covers that specific technique. For a cast iron pan sear, boneless is the practical choice.
US pan-sear recipes converge on the same seasoning: salt, pepper, maybe garlic. This recipe uses something different, and the difference is worth explaining.
Mustard seeds (whole, dry): when mustard seeds hit hot fat, they pop and toast. This does two things. They add a textural element to the crust — small bursts of crunch distinct from the seared meat surface. They also release a mild, nutty heat that is less aggressive than black pepper and integrates into the fat rather than sitting on top of it. Use a small amount — roughly half a teaspoon per steak. They intensify when toasted and too many overwhelm the beef.
Dried chimichurri (chimichurri seco): this is not the fresh sauce. Chimichurri seco is the dried spice blend: sweet red pepper, oregano, parsley, and other dried aromatics — sold in every Argentine supermarket. Used as a rub, it gives the crust a herbaceous, slightly smoky character. No US recipe uses it this way. If you cannot find chimichurri seco, combine half a teaspoon of dried oregano, half a teaspoon of sweet paprika, and a quarter teaspoon of dried parsley as a substitute.
Marine salt (sal gruesa): coarse-grained salt with a mineral depth that fine table salt does not have. Maldon sea salt flakes work. Standard kosher salt also works. The point is coarse grain — it creates texture on the surface and seasons in layers rather than dissolving into a uniform crust.
The combination goes on before the pan: massage olive oil into both sides first, then the salt, then the dried chimichurri. The mustard seeds go into the pan with the butter later, not on the steak before cooking, or they fall off during the sear.
Cast iron is the correct pan for this. It holds heat evenly across the entire surface, it reaches and maintains the temperature needed for the Maillard reaction (the chemical process that creates the brown crust) and it tolerates the high heat required without warping. A stainless steel pan also works. Non-stick does not — it cannot get hot enough without off-gassing and the surface does not develop the same crust character.
Take the steaks out of the fridge a full hour before cooking. Not 20 minutes. A full hour. The reason is heat penetration. A cold steak centre absorbs heat more slowly than the outside surface. By the time the outside has a proper sear, the inside of a cold steak is still raw. A room-temperature steak cooks more evenly from edge to centre. This is the single most important preparation step and the most consistently skipped.
Heat the cast iron on high for 3 minutes before the steak goes in. The pan should be visibly smoking lightly. Add a thin coat of oil with a high smoke point — avocado oil or refined sunflower oil. Not olive oil for this stage: olive oil’s smoke point is too low and it burns at searing temperature.
Pat the steaks dry before they go in. Surface moisture creates steam, and steam prevents the Maillard reaction. A dry surface sears; a wet surface steams and goes grey.
After the first side sears for 3 to 4 minutes, before you flip to the second side, stand the steak on its fat cap edge and hold it there for 1 to 1.5 minutes. Use tongs to keep it upright.
The fat cap is a thick layer of subcutaneous fat along one edge of the ribeye. Left unrendered, it is chewy and unpleasant. Rendered properly, it becomes golden and crisp, and the fat that melts out bastes the sides of the steak as you hold it vertical. In Argentine butchery, the fat cap is left on and rendered — trimming it before cooking is not done. The fat is considered part of the cut’s character, not something to remove.
You will know it is ready when the white fat has turned golden and translucent, with slightly crisped edges. At that point, lay the steak flat and sear the second side for 3 to 4 minutes.
Once the second side is searing, add the butter, crushed garlic, fresh thyme, fresh rosemary, dried chimichurri, and mustard seeds directly to the pan. The butter melts immediately into the residual fat from the steak. Tilt the pan slightly and use a spoon to continuously pour the foaming butter over the top surface of the steak — the side facing up.
The reason you add butter only now: butter burns at around 300°F / 150°C. The pan needs to be at 450–500°F / 230–260°C for the sear. If you add butter at the start, it blackens and turns bitter before the crust can form. Adding it after the main sear gives you flavoured butter at the correct moment — still hot enough to baste, not hot enough to char.
Baste for 3 to 4 minutes. The mustard seeds will pop in the butter. This is normal and desirable. The garlic should turn golden but not brown. If the garlic is going dark, lower the heat slightly. The herbs wilt and infuse into the butter.
Take the steak off the heat and rest it for 2 to 3 minutes on a board. What you will see is red liquid emerging from the cut surface. This is not blood — it is myoglobin, a protein that carries oxygen in muscle tissue and is pink in solution. The heat pushes it through the fibres as the steak cooks. Resting allows the muscle fibres to relax and reabsorb that liquid. Cut immediately and you lose it to the board.
Before slicing, look at the grain. Muscle fibres run in a direction visible on the cut surface as long, parallel lines. Cutting parallel to those lines leaves long, tough fibres in each slice. Cutting across them, perpendicular to the grain, shortens the fibres and produces a more tender bite. Ribeye has a relatively short grain that is easy to identify. Slice across it in cuts about 1cm thick.
Once sliced, pour the leftover garlic and herb butter from the pan directly over the top. Add a final pinch of marine salt. Serve immediately. For the full steak timing guide across different thicknesses and methods, that article covers everything in detail.
Remove the steak from the pan when the internal temperature is 5°F / 3°C below your target. Carryover cooking accounts for the rest: the internal temperature continues to rise by 5°F during resting. A steak pulled at 125°F will rest to 130°F. My preference is 130°F / 54°C: medium-rare, pink and warm throughout, with the fat fully rendered.
★ Medium-rare is my recommendation for ribeye. At 130°F the intramuscular fat has rendered fully, the muscle fibres are tender, and the juices are still in the meat. Well-done ribeye is not ruined, but the fat renders out rather than into the meat, and the texture tightens noticeably. If you prefer well-done, choose a thicker cut with more visible marbling to compensate for what is lost in cooking.
In Argentina, a pan-seared ribeye comes to the table with chimichurri on the side. Not cooked into the steak, but served separately and spooned over at the table. The acidity of the fresh chimichurri cuts through the fat of the pan-seared crust in a way that roasted vegetables or compound butter does not.
If you have made this steak as part of a larger spread, provoleta (grilled Argentine provolone) comes out first, then the ribeye alongside a simple green salad with oil and lemon. No heavy sauces. The steak and the chimichurri do the work.
For wine, Malbec is the obvious match: the dark fruit and firm tannins work with the seasoned crust and the fat. A Mendoza Malbec at room temperature alongside a medium-rare ribeye is as Argentine as it gets in a kitchen setting.
If you want this steak in its proper outdoor context, cooked on a live fire as part of a full Argentine asado, the method changes significantly. The parrilla version uses indirect heat, no pan, and a different timing structure entirely.
For leftover ribeye, this guide on reheating steak without losing flavour gives you the oven method that avoids the rubbery texture you get from a microwave.
Pan not hot enough. The most common error. A warm pan does not sear. It steams. The Maillard reaction requires the meat surface to reach above 285°F / 140°C. If the steak is sizzling quietly rather than aggressively, the pan is not hot enough. Heat it on high for a full 3 minutes before the steak goes in. The oil should shimmer and smoke slightly when it hits the surface.
Steak cold from the fridge. Cold protein contracts when it hits heat. The outside is cooked before the inside reaches temperature. One hour at room temperature is not optional for a steak of this thickness — it is the reason the inside cooks evenly.
Adding butter too early. Butter browns at 300°F / 150°C and burns at 350°F / 175°C. Searing temperature is 450–500°F / 230–260°C. Butter added before the sear blackens, tastes bitter, and coats the pan in carbon that transfers to the steak. Add it only after both sides are seared and the fat cap is rendered.
Cutting without resting. The muscle fibres contract under heat and squeeze liquid toward the centre of the steak. Two to three minutes of rest allows them to relax and reabsorb that liquid. Skip the rest and it runs straight onto the board when you cut.
Cutting with the grain. Long fibres in each slice make the meat feel chewy regardless of how well it was cooked. Observe the grain direction before you cut: it varies by cut and by the individual animal. Always slice across it. For more on this and other common steak mistakes, that article covers them in detail.
Under-salting. Ribeye needs more salt than you think, applied before cooking. Salt draws moisture to the surface briefly, then the meat reabsorbs it along with the dissolved seasoning — this is the dry-brining principle. Season generously, then let it sit. If the steak tastes flat after cooking, it was under-salted before the pan.
For a 1 to 1.5-inch ribeye at medium-rare, sear the first side for 3 to 4 minutes on high heat, render the fat cap vertically for 1 to 1.5 minutes, then sear the second side for 3 to 4 minutes. Add butter and aromatics and baste for a further 3 to 4 minutes. Total active cook time is about 10 to 12 minutes. Grass-fed beef cooks roughly 30% faster at the same thickness — reduce each interval by 30 to 45 seconds and check internal temperature at the 8-minute mark.
Medium-rare ribeye reaches an internal temperature of 130°F / 54°C. Pull the steak from the pan at 125°F / 52°C — carryover cooking during the 2 to 3 minute rest raises it to 130°F. Use an instant-read thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the steak, away from any fat seams. Finger-press testing is not reliable enough for a cut this expensive.
Use a high-smoke-point oil (avocado or refined sunflower) for the initial sear and add butter only after both sides are seared. Butter has a smoke point of around 300°F / 150°C — far below the 450–500°F needed to form a proper crust. Adding butter too early causes it to burn and turn bitter before the Maillard reaction can complete. The butter goes in with the aromatics for basting, not at the start.
Three factors: a very hot pan, a dry steak surface, and room-temperature meat. Pat the steak completely dry before it goes in — surface moisture creates steam that prevents browning. The pan must be smoking before the steak makes contact. And the steak must be at room temperature so the cold interior does not absorb heat that should be forming the crust. All three must be right simultaneously; fixing only one of them will not produce a proper sear.
2 to 3 minutes for a steak of this thickness. Longer than that and the steak arrives cold. The rest allows the muscle fibres to relax and reabsorb the liquid that heat pushed toward the centre during cooking. What you see coming out of a freshly cut steak is not blood — it is myoglobin, a muscle protein. Resting reduces how much of it you lose to the board.
Ojo de bife is the Argentine name for ribeye: the boneless center of the rib primal, without the cap muscle. Bife de chorizo is the Argentine name for what Americans call the New York strip, despite the confusing name (it has nothing to do with chorizo sausage). Both are premium cuts from the short loin and rib sections. The ribeye has more intramuscular fat and a richer flavour; the strip is leaner with a firmer texture. Both work with the pan-sear technique in this recipe.
Both. Massage a thin coat of olive oil into the steak surface before seasoning, which helps the dry seasoning adhere and creates a base for the crust. Then add a separate thin coat of high-smoke-point oil to the hot pan just before the steak goes in. The pan oil initiates the Maillard reaction at contact. The oil on the steak surface develops into part of the crust.
Yes, with adjustments. A frozen ribeye sears more evenly in some respects, because the interior heats more slowly, giving you a wider window before the centre overcooks. Sear from frozen at the same high heat, but expect each side to take 6 to 8 minutes instead of 3 to 4, and the total cook time to roughly double. Use a thermometer rather than timing — the frozen starting temperature makes time-based estimates unreliable. The fat cap rendering and butter basting steps apply identically.
The two steps people skip are room temperature rest and fat cap rendering. Get those right and the rest follows. Everything else is execution. Get those two right and the rest follows.
If you want to go further with Argentine steak: the outdoor fire, the full asado sequence, the parrilla build – the Build Grill Blueprint covers all of it from the ground up.
Discover the first-ever English-speaking Argentine Asado DIY Building Guide, a digital experience designed to help you build your own authentic Asado grill, master the craft of Argentine grilling, and join our community that lives and breathes fire, food, and tradition.
On a Sunday in Buenos Aires, the fire goes on at noon. The vacío will not come off the grill until late afternoon. Between those two points, nobody rushes. The choripán comes first, while the coals develop. Then the mollejas. Then the tira de asado. Then the vacío. Then the provoleta, melting in its pan […]
Argentina eats approximately 500 million choripanes a year. That number becomes easier to understand the first time you smell chorizo smoke outside a Buenos Aires football stadium, or arrive at an asado and find the first thing off the grill waiting for you on a piece of toasted French bread before the main cuts are […]
The empanada recipe most sites give you calls for butter dough and a few spices in the filling. It produces something edible. It is not Argentine. Argentine empanada dough uses beef tallow. The filling is 1:1 onion to beef by weight. It goes into the pastry cold: not warm, not room temperature. Anything above fridge […]
