July 2, 2024

Smoking vs Grilling: Pros, Cons, and How to Choose

If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably found yourself torn between these two methods of cooking meat: smoking vs grilling. Should you fire up the Argentine parrilla for a full asado or commit to a smoker’s slow process? While these two options may seem similar, they are not.  Let’s explore the pros and cons of […]

Daniela Solis

July 2, 2024

If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably found yourself torn between these two methods of cooking meat: smoking vs grilling.

Should you fire up the Argentine parrilla for a full asado or commit to a smoker’s slow process? While these two options may seem similar, they are not. 

Let’s explore the pros and cons of each method, and I’ll even throw in some recipes that’ll make your neighbors peek over the fence. Ready?

What’s the Difference Between Smoking and Grilling?

Grilling usually means cooking food over direct heat, using a gas grill or charcoal, with heat often medium to high. Argentine asados are a type of grilling, but don’t you think this means fast cooking! 

Proper Asado takes time, patience, preparation, and skill. We slowly cook our meat over hot coals or embers, carefully managing the fire’s intensity. This method gives us the perfect crust for different cuts of meat while keeping the inside juicy.

Smoking is all about cooking low and slow. Using wood smoke, you cook the food with indirect heat at lower temperatures, usually between 225-275°F (107-135°C). This smoke cooks the food and adds flavor, working great for bigger, tougher cuts of meat that need time to get tender.

Some grills can do both jobs, letting you switch between grilling and smoking. It’s handy if you want to try different cooking styles.

smoking or grilling

Smoking: Pros and Cons

People have been smoking food for thousands of years. At first, it was a way to preserve meat but now it’s a popular cooking style in many cultures. In the US, barbecue smokehouses are famous, while in Argentina, we have our own smoking traditions, especially in Patagonia, where smoking fish and meat is common.

Types of smokers 

There are a few types of smokers:

  • Electric smokers: Easy to use, great for beginners
  • Charcoal smokers: Give food a nice smoky flavor
  • Wood smokers: The most traditional, offers the strongest smoke taste

You can smoke all sorts of food! Meats like brisket, pork shoulder, and ribs are classics. But don’t stop there – try smoking fish, cheese, or even vegetables.

Pros:

  • Amazing flavor: The smoke gives food a unique taste
  • Tender meat: Long, slow cooking makes tough cuts super soft
  • Fun to experiment: You can try different wood types for various flavors

Cons:

  • Takes time: Smoking isn’t quick – it can take hours
  • Needs attention: You have to watch the temperature and add wood chips
  • Weather dependent: Wind and rain can affect your smoke and ruin the experience.

Grilling: Pros and Cons

Grilling is as old as fire itself! In Argentina, asado is more than cooking – a social event. Families and friends gather around the grill, sharing food and stories and celebrating big events like the World Cup or birthdays. It’s a big part of our culture!

Types of grills 

We have a few types:

  • Gas grills: Quick to heat up, easy to control
  • Charcoal grills: Give food a smoky flavor, loved by many asado fans
  • Wood-fired grills: Traditional method, great for authentic taste

If you’re looking for grilling meat ideas, here’s some good news: You can grill almost anything! Steaks, chorizos, and vegetables are popular. In Argentina, we love grilling different cuts of beef, from bife de chorizo to tira de asado.

Pros:

  • Great flavor: Meat grilling gives food a delicious charred taste
  • Versatile: You can grill many types of food
  • Social: Perfect for gatherings and parties

Cons:

  • Can dry out food: It’s easy to overcook if you’re not careful
  • Needs attention: You have to watch the food to prevent burning
  • Weather dependent: Rain can put a damper on your grilling plans
smoking grilling

Is Smoking Meat Healthier Than Grilling?

This is a question I get a lot, but it’s not a simple yes or no answer. Let’s look at the details:

  • Both methods can be part of a healthy diet if done right.
  • Smoking and grilling don’t add calories, which is good news for us asado lovers.
  • Grilling can help meat release some fat, making it a bit leaner.
  • Smoking meat doesn’t cause fat loss similarly, but it doesn’t add fat either.

But we also need to pay attention when deciding between smoking and grilling:

  • When meat is charred or cooked at very high temperatures, both smoking and grilling can create chemicals called PAHs and HCAs.
  • These chemicals might potentially increase cancer risk if you eat a lot of charred meat often.
  • Smoked foods can be high in salt, which can be considered, according to some medical sources, not healthy.

Tips for healthier smoking and grilling 

Don’t worry – we can still enjoy our asados and keep things healthy. Try these tips when considering whether to use a smoker vs grill:

  1. Trim the excess fat or membranes. Less fat means less dripping and less smoke.
  2. Marinate your meat to reduce harmful chemical formation.
  3. Remove your meat from packaging 2-6 hours before putting it on the grill (especially if it’s vacuum-packed). This will allow it to breathe before hitting the hot grill.
  4. Don’t char your food. A little crust is good, but avoid burning.
  5. Make sure to put your meat on the grill when its at room temperature vs putting it on the grill directly from the fridge when the meat is cold. 
  6. Use a drip pan to catch fat and reduce flare-ups.
  7. Grill more veggies. They don’t form as many harmful chemicals as meat.
  8. Keep portions reasonable. Enjoy your asado, but don’t overdo it!

Remember, it’s all about balance. A good asado now and then, with plenty of veggies and some lean cuts like bife de chorizo, can be part of a healthy lifestyle. Most importantly, enjoy your Argentine asado and the company you share it with!

Ready to Experiment with the Best Cooking Method?

Smoking and grilling both give us amazing flavors, but they work differently. Smoking is all about patience – low heat, lots of time, and incredible wood smoke flavor. Grilling, or as we say, asado, is about managing the fire, getting that perfect crust, and enjoying the process with friends and family.

So, which one’s better? Honestly, that’s like asking me to choose between chimichurri and salsa criolla – they’re both great! It depends on what you’re cooking, your time, and what flavors you’re after.

My advice? Don’t limit yourself to smoking vs barbecue! Try both methods. Experiment with different woods for smoking and play around with coal arrangements for your asado. The more you try, the better you’ll get at both.

Summary
Smoking vs Grilling: Pros, Cons, and How to Choose
Article Name
Smoking vs Grilling: Pros, Cons, and How to Choose
Description
Discover the pros and cons of smoking vs grilling, and explore delicious recipes for both methods. Learn which cooking style suits your taste and lifestyle best with Argentine Asado!
Author
Publisher Name
Argentine Asado

Join 2,000+ subscribers

:data: What's in it for You Every Month on Saturday?
  • Exclusive Recipes: Mouth-watering dishes that'll make your BBQ the talk of the town.
  • Expert Tips: From choosing the right cuts to mastering the "Asado" grill, I've got you covered.
  • Community Stories: Join a passionate community of grillers sharing tips, stories, and more!
:regalo: Special Bonus: Sign up now and get a FREE guide: "5 Secrets to Perfect Asado Every Time"
We care about your data in our privacy policy
Our blog

Lastest blog posts

Tool and strategies modern teams need to help their companies grow.

6 Argentinian Traditions Around Argentine Asado

Hey, there! Grab your mate and get comfortable because we’re about to dive into the heart and soul of Argentina – the traditions around Argentine asado! We’re not talking about meat or the fire today. Nope, we’re going to go deep into about the Argentinian traditions that make asados more than just a barbecue. 1- […]
Jason Pittock
July 21, 2024
Read more

How to prepare Mollejas: The best sweetbread recipe you’ll ever find

Hey there! Today, we’re tackling a cut that might be new to some of you, but trust me, it’s a game-changer on the grill. I’m talking about mollejas, an achura also known as sweetbreads. Don’t let the name fool you – these aren’t sweet and they’re definitely not bread.  What Are Sweetbreads? What are sweetbreads, […]
Jason Pittock
July 16, 2024
Read more

Argentine Vacío vs Asado, What’s the Difference?

Ready to dive deeper into the world of Argentine grilling? Today, we’re tackling a question that often confuses even seasoned asado lovers: What’s the difference between Vacío vs Asado? Trust me, understanding this will take your Argentine asado game to the next level! Let’s break it down and explore these two cuts of Argentine beef […]
Jason Pittock
July 14, 2024
Read more

Join 2,000+ subscribers

:data: What's in it for You Every Month on Saturday?
  • Exclusive Recipes: Mouth-watering dishes that'll make your BBQ the talk of the town.
  • Expert Tips: From choosing the right cuts to mastering the "Asado" grill, I've got you covered.
  • Community Stories: Join a passionate community of grillers sharing tips, stories, and more!
:regalo: Special Bonus: Sign up now and get a FREE guide: "5 Secrets to Perfect Asado Every Time"
Stay in the loop with everything you need to know
We care about your data in our privacy policy
chevron-downarrow-right linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram